The OC Blog Back Issues Our Mission Contact Us Masthead
Sudsy Wants You to Join the Oregon Commentator
 

On The Agenda – Everything: ASUO Senate, 16 February 2011

Kate Bidwell addresses a question from Sen. Tom Schally (foreground) during her confirmation hearing Wednesday. Bidwell was confirmed to Senate Seat 12 (AAA, Psychology, Music) with no nay votes. Photo by Rockne Andrew Roll

News:

EUGENE – Nothing loomed larger over the ASUO Student Senate during its meeting Wednesday evening than the sheer size of the agenda. By the time the meeting had adjourned, senators had filled all its vacancies, dealt with five special requests, publically discussed public records handling and the dwindling surplus, approved the Department Finance Committee’s budget for next year, and gave the Athletics and Contracts Finance Committee more money to fund the Lane Transit District contract.

The meeting commenced with UO Public Records Officer Liz Denecke discussing public records requests and how they affected student government. Denecke explained that, while ASUO records (including emails and other correspondence sent between senators) were considered public records, many of student government’s records were educational records, and thus required a significant amount of sanitization before they could be released in order to comply with federal statutes regarding student records confidentiality. Denecke advised senators to utilize their university email accounts to conduct business regarding the ASUO.

The Senate then moved on to discuss recent expenditures from surplus and their effects on the availability of funds for student groups later in the year. Sen. Evan Thomas expressed dissatisfaction with what he described as excessive allocations over the last few weeks, saying, “I think we have to be more frugal with our money.”

Surplus, the fund consisting of money that programs requested but did not spend during the previous academic year, is the Senate’s main tool for financing the special requests that are brought before it during the year. Many senators were concerned that current surplus levels would leave the body unable to fund large requests from organizations such as sports clubs, which regularly request surplus funds to finance their participation in tournaments and other competitions.

Sen. Brianna Woodside-Gomez, however, did not want these concerns to prevent the Senate from funding other requests that were deserving of student money. “Why is it fair to them that we were fiscally irresponsible before?” Woodside-Gomez said. After some discussion of possible alternatives to the current funding model used for Club Sports, a definitive conclusion was not reached.

The Senate followed the discussion with six special requests. While the Saudi Student Association did not attend to present their request, the Appropriate Dispute Resolution Board was granted a new line item in their budget to fund their attendance of a regional competition and the Multicultural Center, People of the Pacific, and Dance Oregon received a combined total of $7,740 in surplus funds. A request from the American Marketing Association was tabled for next week due to membership requirement concerns.

Transitioning to procedural matters, the Senate then voted on final allocation of $65,000 it had previously earmarked from Over-Realized Funds to fund a concert being planned by the Jewish Student Union for later this year, followed by sending funds received through the Oregon Business Energy Tax Credit to ACFC to help defray the costs of the ASUO’s contract with LTD. The Senate, with little debate, also approved DFC’s budget for next academic year. DFC, the first of the major program budgets to be approved, will distribute $971,528 to 11 campus departments which are fully or partially funded by student fees. This figure represents a 2.6 percent decrease from this year’s funding level, and was approved by a vote of 16 to zero.

Finally, the Senate fully filled its own ranks for only the second time this year with the confirmations of Kate Bidwell and Molly Bacon to Seats 12 (AAA) and 13 (Business), respectively. Bidwell, a graduate student in architecture, was very well received by the senators, who complimented her on her initiative in contacting senators prior to her hearing. “I think you would bring a lot to our Senate and our discussions,” said Rep. Christian Erichsen. Bidwell was confirmed by a vote of 15 to zero, with one abstention.

Bacon, on the other hand, did not have as smooth a hearing. Questions were raised as to her professionalism and qualifications for the position. “I think you need some training in how to conduct yourself in a professional environment,” said Sen. Kaitlyn Lange. Lange continued to say that “I think some business students might be embarrassed.”

The concerns didn’t stop there. “I disagree with your definition of leadership… It just seems a lot about you and how you want to be a leader,” Woodside-Gomez said. Sen. Blake Sedgley also questioned whether, as a pre-business student, Bacon could effectively represent students who were already enrolled in the business school. Nevertheless, by a vote of nine to seven with one abstention, Bacon was confirmed.

After a brief discussion of meeting duration and effectiveness, concluded by Sen. Grace Hochstatter asking senators to “Please think of how you yourself can be more efficient,” the meeting was adjourned.

Lyzi Diamond contributed reporting to this article.

Stats and Opinion after the jump.

Molly Bacon addresses questions from Senators during her confirmation hearing Wednesday night. Photo by Rockne Andrew Roll

Stats:

Meeting Duration: 295 Minutes (One recess)

Money Allocated from Surplus: $7,740 (plus $65,000 from Over-Realized)

Not Present: Dos Santos, Hinman

Resignation Count: 7

Opinion:

So much to say.

The matter of public records is much better handled by Lyzi Diamond in her piece on the subject, so I will leave that to her.

Unfortunately the EMU Board, which finances Club Sports, has already finalized its budget for next year, because I think the current model of funding Club Sports participation in tournament play does need to be addressed. Every time a sports club gets into a big competition, their moment of triumph is tinged with the thought of “how are we going to finance this?” There has to be some reasonable way to determine an amount that is a reasonable prediction of what Club Sports expects to spend (let’s say we take the average from the last five years and add a little room to grow) and allocate that through the EMU Board’s regular budget into a fund which all sports clubs can access, using surplus as a backup if that fund is depleted. Though this would presumably require a significant rewrite to the GTN, I really do think that something different needs to be done.

Senate does spend a lot of money. And while, in recent weeks, senators have been hammering away at groups requesting money, especially those requesting it for conferences, I think more can be done. Woodside-Gomez in correct in saying that it would be wrong to prejudice groups now due to previous funding decisions, so I would suggest tat the Senate should continue, enhance, and perhaps even institutionalize its budding preference for groups that fundraise significant portions of their events budgets and that open participation to all students.

The AMA’s request yesterday evening was unpalatable in light of the $80 membership fee it charges students. Whether that had to do with the national organization wanting high membership dues or the club wanting to pad its own budget (or worse, the club wanting to keep the “riff-raff” out) but at any rate, its unethical.

Though the Constitutional Court has yet to discuss whether graduate students can fill non-graduate seats, a question that I find unlikely to come before them, the precedent has now been set. And that is fine by me. With a strong Executive such as this one, I often worry about appointments being overly loyal to the Executive’s political agenda, but this did not seem to be the case with Bidwell, who’s first vote as a Senator was to not confirm Bacon.

I’m still not sure what to make of Bacon. I did not think she performed well before the Senate, but there’s always the chance that it was nothing more than nerves. Time will tell, I suppose.

This was one hell of a meeting. Next week looks no less intense. Rest up.